By Christina Gilbertson
•
January 28, 2023
We often are asked about non-compete agreements - both from the business's side and from the employee's. As such, we're taking this opportunity to break them down a bit and explain when they're appropriate and enforceable, and when they're not. What is a “non-compete”? In its simplest terms, a non-compete agreement or clause (sometimes also referred to as a “restrictive covenant”) is a legal document wherein an employee agrees not to go to work for an organization's competitor for a set period of time in a certain geographical area after leaving the organization. Non-competes also prohibit the employee from revealing proprietary information or secrets to any other parties during or after employment. What is a “non-solicitation agreement”? Generally speaking, a non-solicitation agreement prevents a former employee from soliciting a certain limited universe of customers or employees of the employer for a period of time. The goals of a non-solicitation are generally more modest than those of a non-compete, and as such, the employer is not seeking to prevent the former employee from gainful employment. Rather, the employer is simply trying to protect its client and employee base from former employees who continue in the same line of business after leaving the employer. In other words, under a non-solicitation agreement, the former employee can still work, but just can’t take the employer’s clients or employees for a stated period of time. Are non-competes and non-solicitations enforceable in Colorado? Yes, but only in EXTREMELY limited situations. In August 2022, Colorado joined the national trend of limiting employer use of non-compete and non-solicit covenants. The new law further provides specific notice requirements and imposes penalties for an employer's non-compliance with the law. The key aspects of the new law are as follows: Non-Competes . Under the new law, Colorado prohibits the use of non-competes and non-solicits except when connected to (1) the sale of a business and (2) when dealing with "highly compensated" workers. A "highly compensated" worker means someone making more than $101,250 per year. This amount will be set annually by the Colorado Department of Labor. Keep in mind that the threshold pay amount must exist at both the time the non-compete is entered into and at the time the employer seeks to enforce the covenant. Non-Solicitations . As noted above, there are typically 2 types of non-solicitation agreements - those involving the solicitation of a company's employees and those involving a company's clients. While the new law doesn't set any specific limitations on the solicitation of employees, any non-solicitation targeting a company's clients will only be upheld against workers who earn 60% of the "highly compensated" threshold, which is currently $60,750. Confidentiality/Non-Disclosure . Fortunately, the new law doesn't invalidate reasonable confidentiality and non-disclosure agreements, is does clarify that the agreements must not prohibit the disclosure of: (1) information arising from the worker's general training, knowledge, skill, or experience, (ii) information that is readily ascertainable to the public; and (iii) information that the worker otherwise has a legal right to disclose. Notice Requirements . Perhaps the biggest change under the new law is are the specific notice requirements that must be afforded to prospective or current workers in order for a non-compete to be enforceable. For prospective workers, the terms of the non-compete must be provided before the worker accepts an offer of employment. For current workers, employers must provide the terms at least 14 days before the effective date of the restriction or change in the condition of employment. The required notice must be in "clear and conspicuous terms in the language in which the worker and employer communicate," and must be signed by the worker. Furthermore, the notice and signature must be on a document that is separate and apart from the document that contains the restrictions. In other words, employers must provide 2 separate documents in order for a non-compete to be enforceable: (1) the notice, and (2) the agreement. Enforcement and Penalties . Another major change in the law is the addition that any employer who enters into, presents to a worker, or attempts to enforce, any void and unenforceable covenant is liable for actual damages and a statutory penalty of $5,000 to the aggrieved worker. Violators will also be liable for attorneys' fees and costs. Actions against an employer may be brought by the aggrieved worker, the Attorney General, and/or the Colorado Division of Labor. Are there additional restrictions on non-compete and non-solicit agreements? Yes. Even if a non-compete or non-solicit may be enforceable, its scope and terms must be “reasonable.” Generally, whether a non-compete is “reasonable” will look to: the duration of the non-compete; the geographical scope; whether the scope of the non-compete is necessary to protect the employer’s interests; and whether the non-compete imposes hardship on the employee. Ultimately, “reasonableness” is determined on a case-by-case basis, as there is no general rule as to what is reasonable in any given context. How can a business enforce a non-compete? A court can award an employer the following remedies for violation of a valid non-compete in Colorado: injunctive relief (essentially a court-order precluding the employee from the competitive employment); damages (i.e., loss of profits), and costs & attorney’s fees. Generally speaking, injunctive relief is the most common method of enforcing a valid on-compete, as damages can be difficult to establish. In some cases, the competitor that hired the employee subject to the non-compete may also be found liable if they intentionally induced the employee to breach the non-compete. Prior to the recent law change, it was often commonplace for employers to include non-competes and non-solicits in contracts with the knowledge that they were unlikely to be enforced. The point of this was to act as a deterrent to workers going to work for competitors or starting their own competing business. Given the express penalties noted above, this practice will no longer be tolerated, and company's can find themselves on the wrong end of significant fines and damages. If you have a non-compete clause in your employment contracts, schedule a call with us today so that we can evaluate it and help you determine whether the non-compete would be enforceable, or if there’s something you can do to better protect your company. Additionally, if you intend to use non-competes, make sure you're providing separate notice to your workers to comply with the notice requirements.